I was fortunate to live in Strasbourg, France following graduation from University. Years later, I ended up teaching World History at the secondary school level. As a former resident of Strasbourg, I was immersed in the rich culture and historical significance of the Alsace region. I spent much of my time walking around the city and surrounding area checking out museums and monuments. I also had the opportunity to speak with elderly Strasbourg natives that had lived through WWI and WWII. One conversation in particular has remained etched in my memory. This particular gentleman lived in the same home his entire life and without ever moving, he said he has been 5 nationalities. He counted -- German, then French...then German again, and then back to French. Then he smiled and said, "Now I am European."
Today, the city of Strasbourg is celebrated as a symbol of European peace and stability. While Brussels is considered a European Union capital, Strasbourg is the headquarters of the EU Parliament building and many other important EU governmental institutions. It is fascinating to think that in one lifetime, the same region that has been a cause for world wars is now the centerpiece for a peaceful cooperation among many historic foes. I have always shared this "outside-school-content-area-expanding-experience" to my students when we study WWI and WWII. I believe they appreciate the non-textbook anecdote that provides more context and texture to their reading assignments.
Today, the city of Strasbourg is celebrated as a symbol of European peace and stability. While Brussels is considered a European Union capital, Strasbourg is the headquarters of the EU Parliament building and many other important EU governmental institutions. It is fascinating to think that in one lifetime, the same region that has been a cause for world wars is now the centerpiece for a peaceful cooperation among many historic foes. I have always shared this "outside-school-content-area-expanding-experience" to my students when we study WWI and WWII. I believe they appreciate the non-textbook anecdote that provides more context and texture to their reading assignments.
Response to Class Discussion of Ball's, "The Subject Matter Preparation of Teachers"
It was interesting to hear various viewpoints. In particular, I observed a few categories of opinions. Multiple Subject vs. Single Subject and then those with a few years of classroom experience and those without many years.
In general, I was most curious to hear from Multiple-Subject teachers with little classroom experience. I sympathize with the daunting thought of having to 'know everything', as required for a Multiple-Subject teacher. I recall feeling uncomfortable with my level of content knowledge as a Single-Subject teacher -- in spite of the fact that I had a degree in a Social Science. However, after teaching for a few years, I grew in a comfort level with what I did know, while cognizant that I still know little (relative to everything) but had a desire to keep learning more. I have continued to increase my content area knowledge by reading, watching films, and through conversations with colleagues, classmates, and professors. I conclude that there is no simple answer to the questions, "how much content knowledge is enough to be a good teacher?" and, "where can I learn enough to be a good teacher?" As I shared in the class discussion, the standardized test (CSET) is one way to assess how much a teacher knows... and passing it provided a boost of confidence for what I felt my level of content knowledge is. However, as I mentioned above, I still know little ... relative to everything.
Status of My "Question", etc.
I am very confident in my question and am moving forward with further research. I have already set up some preliminary experiential learning experiences in the form of interviews from key people who have been instrumental in the formation of the modern Napa Valley. I also have contacted colleagues who have experience in this subject who can point me in the right direction for primary and secondary sources.
***I commented on Alex Iwaszewicz, Jerry Cauchi, and Alana Scott.
What a great experience living in Strasbourg. Your kids must love the stories. I think your topic should be interesting and certainly something your students can relate to.
ReplyDeleteTom, I like your question of inquiry dealing with the formation of the modern Napa Valley. In the introductory class when you first mentioned your question with the class I couldn’t help but think about that movie Bottle Shock. It is placed in the 70’s when a British wine enthusiast living in Paris wants to compare the emerging wine production of Napa with the legendary quality of French wines. That could be a helpful secondary source for you and if not could just appeal to your personal interest. If you haven’t seen the movie yet I’d strongly recommend it and I hope that the rest of your inquiry goes well it defiantly sounds interesting and can see the students really engaging in understanding the history of their local area. Have fun and enjoy some wine while doing your experimental learning experiences.
ReplyDeleteTom, I would think that you would have a wealth of sources available to you covering all types of research. The area is certainly rich with historical tales, drama and controversy. Let me know if you ever need any help with a experiential research (I am thinking a trip to an old winery might be called for here ;-).
ReplyDeleteSeriously, this is a great way to help engage your students. During my last student teaching placement (in Pittsburg) I found how little students knew about the history of their own backyard. I was pleasantly surprised by the response of many students, who wanted to know more about the area they lived in as well. Several took this information home with them and returned with 'realia' as well as commentary about their own history.
Good luck.
Tom--
ReplyDeleteThank you for our great conversation on Tuesday. I am not only excited about your research but also your future path in education. I'm certain that your new position is providing a whole new perspective.
Here is the link to the book I mentioned:
http://www.amazon.com/Napa-The-Story-American-Eden/dp/0618257985/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1341548417&sr=8-1&keywords=Napa